Skip to main content


SFFBookClub December poll

Alright, getting #SFFBookClub back on track. Two new options this month:

Light From Uncommon Stars is from a private toot, so if the recommender wants to make themselves known it's up to them to reply. More info: us.macmillan.com/books/9781250…

Wondrous Journeys in Strange Lands is from @SoniaSulaiman's #ReadPalestinianSpecFic list at soniasulaiman.com/readpalestin… . Book info: simonandschuster.com/books/Won…

As always, the list of previously read titles is at docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d… . And as always, replies to either advocate for one of the options or suggest titles for future months are very welcome.

  • The Way Spring Arrives & Other Stories (various) (0%, 0 votes)
  • Semiosis, by Sue Burke (0%, 0 votes)
  • Light From Uncommon Stars, by Ryka Aoki (33%, 1 vote)
  • Wondrous Journeys in Strange Lands, by Sonia Nimr (66%, 2 votes)
3 voters. Poll end: 9 months ago

in reply to Eldan Goldenberg

The #SFFBookClub December pick is Wondrous Journeys In Strange Lands, by Sonia Nimr. Thank you everyone who voted or suggested a book.
in reply to Eldan Goldenberg

SFFBookClub January poll

Having done two sequels months in the past half year, I'd like to actually pick a book for #SFFBookClub January. Two new selections this time, suggested by @picklish & @DejahEntendu . Their links:

weirder.earth/@picklish/110602…

dice.camp/@DejahEntendu/111469…

As always, replies to advocate for a favoured book and/or suggest more titles for the future are very welcome. The current queue and list of past reads are at docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d…

  • Semiosis, by Sue Burke (0%, 0 votes)
  • Light From Uncommon Stars, by Ryka Aoki (25%, 1 vote)
  • Siren Queen, by Nghi Vo (0%, 0 votes)
  • How High We Go In The Dark, by Sequoia Nagamatsu (75%, 3 votes)
4 voters. Poll end: 8 months ago

in reply to Eldan Goldenberg

The #SFFBookClub January pick is How High We Go In The Dark, by Sequoia Nagamatsu. Thank you to all who voted and/or suggested books.
in reply to Eldan Goldenberg

SFFBookClub February poll & March sequels month

For February: both new options are titles that have been rumoured to have been censored out of the Hugos. I haven't been following that controversy closely enough to know how solid the evidence is, but they both sound interesting anyway so I figured I'd include them: harpercollins.com/products/bab… & xiranjayzhao.com/index.php/boo…

As usual, please vote, and replies to advocate for one of the choices or suggest future picks are always very welcome.

Advance notice for March: that will be the next Sequels Month purely because I have some travel coming up that will make keeping up with a poll more hassle than usual.

#SFFBookClub

  • Light From Uncommon Stars, by Ryka Aoki (0%, 0 votes)
  • Siren Queen, by Nghi Vo (0%, 0 votes)
  • Babel, by R.F. Kuang (33%, 1 vote)
  • Iron Widow, by Xiran Jay Zhao (66%, 2 votes)
3 voters. Poll end: 7 months ago

in reply to Eldan Goldenberg

SFFBookClub February poll & March sequels month

I'd like to read Babel. I already read the Poppy Wars trilogy and enjoyed it quite a lot, though there were some rather dismal parts.

Already read Iron Widow. It's interesting, though a bit YA-ish.

in reply to modulux

SFFBookClub February poll & March sequels month
We seem to end up doing about one YA title a year, and they're usually a mixture of good and bad lightness. Often a nice break after something very heavy (e.g. this month's pick outside.ofa.dog/book/2743/s/ho… ), but also usually a bit "thin" in character development and/or resolving tensions too easily. Does that sound like your impression of Iron Widow?
in reply to Eldan Goldenberg

SFFBookClub February poll & March sequels month
Yeah, I wouldn't say resolves tensions too easily, maybe, but character motivations are a little thin, a bit stereotyped. Almost like evil archetypes that can't change sometimes. That said, there's also pretty violent stuff, so it's not YA-ish in that regard. Also some of the world-building feels a bit inspired by cartoon conventions, which makes it seem that way to me but that may be a personal bias.
in reply to Eldan Goldenberg

SFFBookClub February poll & March sequels month

I was already thinking of rereading Iron Widow before the sequel comes out at the end of April, so that has my vote this time around.

This is definitely quite a line-up though.

in reply to enne 💤

SFFBookClub February poll & March sequels month
Agreed about this being a good lineup. I was planning to read Babel when it was first released, but it always got bumped for something I was more interested in. Then it was late enough I decided to wait until the Hugo noms were released since I figured it would be included. When it wasn't, I pushed it even further down the list. I have a renewed interest now because it does appear to have been wrongfully disqualified.
Siren Queen has also been on my list for a while. I'm just learning about Iron Window, and I've already read Light from Uncommon Stars. (Note to Eldang: Stars is very heavy on the violins.)
in reply to Will :he_him:

SFFBookClub February poll & March sequels month
Bonus! Babel is currently US$1.99 as an ebook from both Kobo and Amazon.
#SFFBookClub
in reply to Will :he_him:

SFFBookClub February poll & March sequels month
I just couldn't resist and started reading it.
in reply to Eldan Goldenberg

SFFBookClub February: Babel

Sensitive content

in reply to Eldan Goldenberg

SFFBookClub April poll

Sensitive content

⇧