For those who used all three of Whatsapp, Signal and Delta Chat in multi-device mode:

Which messenger provides the best multi-device setup and handling for users (UX)?

(question spans setting up a second/linked device, as well as migrating to new device, as well as quality of multi-device synchronizing/bugfree-ness -- all subjectively weighted by each voter according to their subjective experiences)

  • Signal (28%, 46 votes)
  • Whatsapp (5%, 8 votes)
  • Delta Chat (53%, 86 votes)
  • other (please name in reply) (12%, 20 votes)
160 voters. Poll end: 1 week ago

ArcaneChat reshared this.

in reply to stevejohnson42

ah -- we should have said that we were only looking at end-to-end encrypted messengers. Telegram is a fancy and fast clear-text central database viewer, not a private messenger. It has good messenger UX, and provides messaging, and naturally has a lot less problems with showing everything with just a login to their central database. so pretty easy for multi-device.
This entry was edited (1 week ago)
in reply to Delta Chat

@fu I know that there is no all-platforms app for #XMPP, but I don't see that as a disadvantage. Every app that you are used to use is 'good'.
My personal setup is #Conversations on my Android machines and #Gajim on Linux and Windows. For iOS (I don't use Apple devices, though) I recommend #Monal, which I see as the most advanced app for XMPP on Apple. On Linux, #Dino is very promising, and I might switch in the future
in reply to Delta Chat

DC is easily my favorite UX of these 3 because any device can be the primary - needing to create accounts on Whatsapp and Signal with a phone and tie a phone number to the account before creating a quite awkward secondary on a computer is, especially after that WA data leak, pretty unfortunate.

other folks have mentioned some Matrix and XMPP clients, and while I understand why DC does everything with QR codes to mitigate MITM attacks, it does make that standard workflow of scanning a QR code off a phone into the computer a pain in the neck. Matrix's approach to a username/password and then key syncing via emoji checking is really universal and slick.

in reply to Delta Chat

@Delta Chat it used to be signal of the three but they've made that more difficult particularly when using with two different phones with their own phone number. For most this probably isn't a normal use case but those off is with separate work and personal devices who prefer to have the same conversations available on both phones that sucks.

Of the OTHER options I have had best experience with XMPP based apps like CONVERSATIONS.

I more-or-less gave up on Delta chat because I couldn't get multiple devices working right between my personal Android phone and work Windows laptop.

in reply to Nintendo User

@feld that wasn't the case at the time, though years later security requirements have changed to the point it wouldn't even be possible for me to test this. Since I spend like 12 hours a day on my work laptop, more often doing personal stuff then work stuff, not having that option makes it even less likely I'll actually use DeltaChat. I'm really wish I could use a webclient for delta chat. (And no, using my regular webmail client doesn't count).
in reply to 𝖏𝖆𝖊[Ø]™

@jae @zaire @r10s we could make it work over the Internet (using the same technique as what webxdc.org/docs/spec/joinRealt… offers, using "Iroh" under the hood) but we decided against it for now. It fundamentally prevents exploits like thehackernews.com/2025/02/hack…