I think my paper on Dummett, proof assistants and pluralism has shaped up rather nicely, and it will be good to see it out in the Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society in a few months’ time. You can read the preprint now.
Thanks to everyone who gave me feedback on earlier drafts, and discussed these issues along the way.
There's more to be done, but I hope to have clarified some issues around how we can think about the relationship between constructive and classical reasoning, and how philosophers might engage with what is going on in the application of dependent type theory in proof assistants, programming language design, and the formalisation and mechanisation of reasoning.
Mazhe
in reply to Daniel Gultsch • • •Ch M[ae][iy]e?r 🇪🇺 🖤 🤍
in reply to Daniel Gultsch • • •wouldn't it be better to give users/ admins a hint?
I understand that you want to give best possible user experience to Conversations, but:
As a admin I am interested to improve my server (or maybe I don't want to use STUN at all?), and as a user I would like to switch to a server that fits my needs. 🤔
Using your infrastructure feels bad, because it allows to keep badly hosted servers without noticing it.
Perhaps give a hint to admins, how he can improve it or how to use your services.
Also from a GDPR view:
Does the user agree to contact a server he did not configure himself?
uɐıʇsɐqǝs
in reply to Daniel Gultsch • • •yes.
But communicate clearly about it.
I still encounter people that say "I don't want to use xmpp, it doesn't work" - when the last time they tried was years ago. Bad Ux seems to create long lasting bad impressions.
Markus 🇩🇪 🇪🇺
in reply to Daniel Gultsch • • •ruff
in reply to Daniel Gultsch • • •ZeroZX
in reply to Daniel Gultsch • • •If it can be deactivated in the configuration, then I don't see an issue with that. I would appreciate a warning though somewhere, maybe just a Message Toast on both sides that the fallback is used. That would help notice wrong configurations.
It would be great if conversations could verify that stun/turn works completely in addition to that. (Might also be a separate tool).